"JOURNAL OF RADIO ELECTRONICS" N 5, 2007
Integrated-optical low-loss PbO2 diffusion waveguide sensitive chemical sensor
A. A. Egorov, M.A. Egorov, R.B. Smoliakov, T.K. Chekhlova, A.G. Timakin
Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia, Moscow, Russia
Received May 4, 2007
We created an innovated opto-electronic system where integrated-optical sensor, photodetectors, microelectronic comparison scheme, analog-to-digital converter and computer are integrated with the aim to achieve a high sensitivity. The test of this system demonstrates that this sensor can detect the ammonia with the concentration 4 ppm for a signal-to-noise-ratio about 15.
The detection of gases as CO, NOx, NH3, SOx, O3 is an important task in the different areas: environmental monitoring, physical ecology, medicine, chemistry, defense and citizens protection. There are different types of sensors. Their functioning principles are based on certain physical and chemical effects. Sensors permit to determine various parameters: location, temperature, pressure, humidity, gas concentration, fingerprint, and others [1-5]. Physical ecology, in particular, necessitates the development of sensors that enable one to determine various environmental parameters: temperature, pressure, humidity, and gas concentration.
The progress in physical ecology and environmental monitoring in our opinion is closely related to the development of new type sensors – optical sensors. The interest in the development and application of optical chemical sensors is related to their advantages: high sensitivity, fast response, simplicity of signal multiplexing, and application of integrated technologies [1, 6, 7]. Integrated-optical chemical sensors are in our opinion the most promising among them [1, 6].
The working principle of integrated-optical chemical sensors is based on the variation in the laser radiation intensity transmitted by the gaseous or liquid substance under study, located in a neighborhood of an integrated-optical sensor, at certain wavelengths characteristic for these substances. The main innovation scientific and engineering task is to elaborate an easy-to-use, compact, accurate, and reliable sensor with fast time of the signal response for measuring the atmospheric concentrations of various substances, including ultra low concentrations.
We demonstrate in this paper an innovated opto-electronic system where integrated-optical sensor, photodetectors, microelectronic comparison scheme, analog-to-digital converter and computer are incorporated for deriving high sensitivity. In our opinion this kind of arrangement is a promising trend in the development of the optical sensors for different high-tech applications. One of these applications can be an optoelectronics system of the climate control, where this sensor detect gas concentration and then a computer send commands to the execution devices, which manage a composition of the air in a locality.
2. Elaboration and testing of an opto-electronic scheme with built-in integrated-optical waveguide chemical sensor cell
Figure 1 demonstrates the elaborated opto-electronic system. A helium-neon laser 1 serves as the radiation source. The laser incident beam is split into a reference and a sensor beams by the half-transparent mirror 2. Sensor beam is input into integrated-optical waveguide at an angle that corresponds to the resonant excitation of TE0-mode. The integrated-optical sensor cell 3 is a diffusion planar waveguide that fabricated by doped PbO2 into plate glass substrate. The cell length i.e. the distance between the input and output prisms is 4 cm. The coupling prisms are made of the TF-5 glass with refractive index of 1.7497 (for wavelength = 632.8 nm).
Fig. 1. Scheme of the elaborated opto-electronic system with integrated-optical sensor cell.
The attenuation of the used waveguide is equal to 0.1 cm-1 for fundamental TE-mode with effective refractive index = 1.521. We used ammonia (NH3) for the tests, because it is one of the significantly important gases for the people protection in the different applications. Note that in the microelectronic industry ammonia is produced, for example, in the photolithographic technological process.
The radiation is output from the waveguide with an output prism and is measured with first photodetector (PD 1), whose signal is fed to comparison electronic scheme 4. The signal of the reference beam, which is measured with second photodetector (PD 2), is also fed to comparison microelectronic scheme 4. The signal after the analog-to-digital conversion is recorded and processed with a computer 5. The microelectronic comparison scheme 4 is created with use of precision operational amplifiers with small voltage of a displacement and high amplification factor of voltage (the amplifiers have an interior frequency correction and have a good combination of parameters of entering voltages and a noise current). In experiment is established, that this microelectronic scheme is sufficiently stable to the mechanical and other noises. In this new experimental setup the data in opposition to our previous  measurement scheme are registering and processing by the computer that permits e.g. rapidly obtain different parameters characterizing experiments.
In accordance with the Bouguer-Lambert-Beer law, we have
where is the radiation power at the exit of the cell in the absence of ammonia; is the output power in the presence of ammonia; is the thickness of the layer of the medium under study, which corresponds to the length of the absorbing cell; is the absorption cross-section of the substance under study (ammonia); and is the measured concentration. We take the ammonia absorption cross-section at the He-Ne laser wavelength ( ≈ 0.63 µm) ≈ 3.8∙10–16 cm2 .
It follows from formula Eq. (1) that the ammonia concentration measured in the experiment is
Using the measured data (on can see in the Figure 2: when ammonia is delivered to the sensor cell, the output laser light power decreases) we have obtained from equation Eq. (2) the experimental ammonia concentration: ≈ 4 ppm.
Now we can find the ammonia concentration measured at the limiting sensitivity of the waveguide sensor cell as follows
where is the noise power measured at the exit of the cell in the absence of ammonia for a long realization. Using this expression Eq. (3) we obtained ≈ 0.1 ppm for the maximum experimental signal-to-noise ratio ≈ 20.
Fig. 2. Example of the sensor response to the presence of ammonia.
In the Fig.3 a fragment of the repeatability test of this sensor system to the relatively identical concentrations of ammonia is depicted. The virtual laboratory “PC-Lab 2000” as a recorder was applied in this test. One can see that elaborated opto-electronic scheme with built-in integrated-optical waveguide cell is adequately sensitive and has enough stable reproducibility of the results (the arithmetic mean deviation of voltage at the moment of ammonia detecting from the average arithmetical value did not surpass 5%).
The experimental value of the ammonia concentration measured with this sensor is about 4 ppm. The time response of the computerized integrated-optical sensor is 0.15 s. The signal-to-noise ratio is about 15. Elaborated integrating opto-electronic system exhibits in experiments sensitivity, accuracy, reproducibility of the results, fast response, and a relatively high signal-to-noise ratio.
Fig. 3. Repeatability test of the sensor to the rather identical concentrations of ammonia.
We do not analyze in the present paper the effect of the waveguide light scattering due to the waveguide irregularities, since this problem is discussed in detail in different books and journals (see for example [7-11]).
– increase in the length of the absorbing cell;
– modification of the configuration of the absorbing cells (application of the Bragg mirrors or a substrate that represents a cylindrical rod) ;
– increase in the signal-to-noise ratio (by using for example waveguides with low roughness substrates);
– integration of the sensor elements (including: radiation source, absorbing cell, photodetectors, comparison microelectronic scheme, and microprocessor) at a single substrate;
– and others.
In this paper we describe an opto-electronic system elaborated with the aim to achieve high stable and sensitive characteristics of the built-in integrated-optical waveguide chemical sensor. As a result the sensitivity of this sensor is increased and time of the signal response is decreased appropriately. The limiting theoretic concentration of these sensors is less 0.1 ppm for the signal-to-noise-ratio more than 20.
In our view, one can use these sensors in the study of both gaseous pollutants and substances dissolved in liquids (e.g., in biomedical, physicochemical, and ecological measurements).
1. Chekhlova T.K., Timakin A.G. and Popov K.A. Waveguide sensors for measuring concentrations of components in gas mixtures and liquids. Instruments and Experimental Techniques, 45, pp. 281-284 (2002).
3. Qiao L., Yong X., Fukang J., Yu-Chong T., and Chih-Ming H. A Parameterized Three-Dimensional Model for MEMS Thermal Shear-Stress Sensors. J. of Microelectromechanical Systems, 14, pp. 625-633 (2005).
4. Posani K.T., Tripathi V., Annamalai S., Weisse-Bernstein N.R., and Krishnaa S. Nanoscale quantum dot infrared sensors with photonic crystal cavity, Appl. Phys. Let., 88, pp. 151104-1–151104-3 (2006).
5. Hiroyuki S., Masahiro Y., Masuyoshi Y., Nagaaki O., Hideaki T., and Takashi O. Experimental evaluation of fingerprint verification system based on double random phase encoding, Optics Express, 14, pp. 1755-1766 (2006).
11. Egorov A.A. Use of waveguide light scattering for precision measurements of the statistical parameters of irregularities of integrated optical waveguide materials, Opt. Eng., 44, pp. 014601-1–014601-10 (2005).