UDC 004.7

INTEROPERABILITY PROBLEM IN NET-CENTRAL MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS

 

S. V. Kozlov ¹, S. I. Makarenko ², A. Ya. Oleinikov ³, D. V. Rastyagaev ⁴, T. E. Chernitskaya ²,

¹ Federal research center «Computer science and Menegement» of  Russian Academy of Science, Vavilova str., 44, build. 2, Moscow 119333, Russia

² Saint Petersburg State Electrotechnical University "LETI", Professora Popova str., 5, Saint Petersburg 197376, Russia

³ Kotelnikov Institute of Radioengineering and Electronics of Russian Academy of Sciences, Mokhovaya str., 11-7, Moscow 125009, Russia

⁴ Russian New University, Radio str., 22, Moscow 105005, Russia

 

 The paper is received on November 10, 2019

 

Abstract. Analysis of papers in the field of network-centric control systems, the principles of their functioning and a problem of interoperability in network-centric systems is carried out. In the paper is shown that interoperability is the main principle of network-centric systems that increases the efficiency of their functioning in relation to classical control systems. The analysis that is presented in the article showed that the research on ensuring interoperability for the network-centric systems is carried out very actively both in civil and military spheres. At the same time, the largest number of studies and results in the field of interoperability of network centric systems ware obtained by the Network Centric Operations Industry Council (NCOIC). In Russia, the scale of research in this field of interoperability is much lower and does not correspond to the real level of importance of this problem. Importance of interoperability study is recognized at the conceptual level. Therefore, this study is aimed at the formulating and finding a solution to the problem of interoperability for network-centric control systems. This study has a high theoretical and practical significance, and in domestic practice is formulated for the first time. The research is carried out within the ¹ 19-07-00774 project of The Russian Foundation for Basic Research.

Keywords: interoperability, network-centric control system, control system, network-centric concept.

References

1.       Makarenko S. I., Ivanov M. S. Setecentricheskaya vojna – principy, tekhnologii, primery i perspektivy. Monografiya [Network-centric warfare - principles, technologies, examples and perspectives. Monograph]. Saint Petersburg, Naukoemkie Tekhnologii Publ., 2018.  898 p. (In Russian)

2.       Burenok V. M. Basis of the next generation of wars. Vestnik akademii voennykh nauk - Bulletin of the Academy of Military Sciences. 2011. No.3. P.32-37. (In Russian)

3.       Rahmanov A. A. Network-centric control systems – accrual tendencies, problem issues and ways of their solution. Voennaya mysl’ - Military Thought. 2011. No.3. P.41-50 (In Russian)

4.       Makarenko S. I Berezhnov A. N. Prospects of using network-centric technologies for the management of the fighting and problems of their implementation in the armed forces of the Russian Federation. Vestnik akademii voennykh nauk - Bulletin of the Academy of Military Sciences. 2011. Vol.37. No.4. P.64-68 (In Russian)

5.       Hersprin D. R. Rumsfeld’s Wars: The Arrogance of Power. Lawrence, Kans., University Press of Kansas, 2008.

6.       Cebrowski A. K., Garstka J. J. Network-Centric Warfare: Its Origin and Future. U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings, 1998.

7.       Alberts D. S., Garstka J. J., Stein F. P. Network Centric Warfare: Developing and Leveraging Information Superiority. US Department of Defense C4ISR Cooperative Research Program Publications Series, 2001. 292 p. Available at: http://www.dodccrp.org/files/Alberts_NCW.pdf (accessed 19 October 2019).

8.       Alberts D. S., Garstka J. J., Hayes R. E., Signori D. A. Understanding Information Age Warfare. Washington, CCRP, 2001. 319 p.

9.       Warden J. A. The Air Campaign: Planning for Combat. National Defense University Press Publication, 1988.

10.  ISO/IEC/IEEE 24765:2017. Systems and software engineering. Vocabulary. ISO, 2017. 522 p.

11.  GOST R 55062-2012. Informacionnye tekhnologii (IT). Sistemy promyshlennoj avtomatizacii i ih integraciya. Interoperabel'nost'. Osnovnye polozheniya [Information technology (IT). Industrial automation systems and their integration. Interoperability. Fundamentals]. Moscow, Standartinform Publ., 2014. 12 p. (In Russian).

12.  Program of fundamental research of the state academies of Sciences for 2013-2020. Order of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 3, 2012 No. 2237-R. Moscow, RAS, 2012. Available at: http://www.ras.ru/FStorage/Download.aspx?id=62d335ba-2aea-4803-85ee-fd0cd37aba4b (accessed 19 October 2019). (In Russian)

13.  Gulyaev Yu. V., Zhuravliov E. E., Oleinkov A. Ya. The methodology of standardization for address the interoperability of information systems of broad classes. Zhurnal Radioelektroniki - Journal of Radio Electronics. 2012. No. 3. Available at: http://jre.cplire.ru/jre/mar12/2/text.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019) (In Russian)

14.  Gulyaev Yu. V., Oleinkov A. Ya. State and prospects of open systems technology development. Informatsionnye tekhnologii i vychislitelnye sistemy - Information Technology and Computing Systems. 2006. No.3. P.7-18 (In Russian).

15.  Oleinkov A. Ya., Razinkin E. I. E-Commerce interoperability profile. Informatsionnye tekhnologii i vychislitelnye sistemy - Information Technology and Computing Systems. 2013. No.4. P.74-79. (In Russian)

16.  Zhuravlev E. E., Ivanov S. V., Kamenshchikov A. A., Kornienko V. N., Oleynikov A. Ya., Shirobokova T. D. Aspects of methodology of ensuring interoperability in the Grid-environment and cloud computing. Komp'yuternyye issledovaniya i modelirovaniye - Computer Research and Modeling. 2015. Vol.7. No.3. P.675-682 (In Russian)

17.  Bystrov R. P., Korniyenko V. N., Oleynikov A. Ya. Interoperability, information antagonism and radio-electronic fight. Uspekhi sovremennoi radioelektroniki – Achievements of Modern Electronics. 2018. No.5. P.15-34 (In Russian)

18.  Olejnikov A. Ya., Egorov G. A., Zhuravlev E. E., Korolev A. S., Kochukov A. N., Shirobokova T. D. Application of open systems technology for creation of integrated information systems of industrial enterprises. Radiopromyshlennost’ - Radio Industry. 2006. No.2. P.90-107. (In Russian)

19.  Oleinikov A. Ya., Kamenshchikov A. A. The role of interoperability in the digital economy and defense capability of the country. IT-Standart  –  IT-Standard, 2017. Vol.13. No.4. P.31-35. (In Russian)

20.  Oleinikov A.Ya., editor. Tekhnologiya otkrytyh sistem. Monografiya [Open systems technology. Monograph]. Moscow, Yanus-K Publ., 2004. 288 p. (In Russian) 

21.  Net-Centric Environment Joint Functional Concept. 2005. Available at: https://dodcio.defense.gov/Portals/0/Documents/netcentric_jic.pdf (accessed 22 October 2019).

22.  Net-Centric Operational Environment Joint Integrating Concept (NCOE). 2005. Available at: https://dodcio.defense.gov/Portals/0/Documents/netcentric_jic.pdf (accessed 22 October 2019).

23.  Department of Defense Net-Centric Services Strategy for a Net-Centric, Service Oriented DoD Enterprise. 2007. Available at: https://dodcio.defense.gov/Portals/0/documents/DoD_NetCentricServicesStrategy.pdf (accessed 22 October 2019).

24.  Department of Defense Enterprise Architecture Transition Strategy. 2008. Available at: http://extras.sltrib.com/Utah_Data_Center/EATransitionStrategy.pdf (accessed 22 October 2019).

25.  Makarenko A. V. Vvedenie v setetsentricheskie informatsionno-upravliaiushchie sistemy [Introduction to network-centric information management systems]. Konstruktivnaia kibernetika. Issledovaniia. Razrabotki. Konsalting [Constructive cybernetics]. Online resource. 2010. Available at: http://www.rdcn.ru/estimation/2010/03042010.shtml (accessed 21 February 2019) (In Russian).

26.  Ìàêàðåíêî À. Â. Paradigma setecentricheskogo upravleniya – sovremennyj vzglyad [The paradigm of network-centric control – a modern view]. Konstruktivnaia kibernetika. Issledovaniia. Razrabotki. Konsalting [Constructive cybernetics]. Online resource. 2010. Available at: http://www.rdcn.ru/estimation/2010/17062010.shtml (accessed 22 October 2019) In Russian).

27.  Efremov A. Yu., Maksimov D. Yu. Setecentricheskaya sistema upravleniya – chto vkladyvaetsya v eto ponyatie? [Network-centric control system-what is included in this concept?]. Trudy 3-j Vserossijskoj konferencii s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem "Tekhnicheskie i programmnye sredstva sistem upravleniya, kontrolya i izmereniya" [Proceedings of the 3rd All-Russian conference with international participation "Technical and software tools of control, control and measurement systems"]. Moscow, Institute of Control Sciences of RAS. 2012. P.158-161 (In Russian).

28.  Trahtengerts E. A., Pashchenko F. F. The use of network-centric principles in the digital economy. Datchiki & Systemi - Sensors and Systems. 2018. Vol.227. No.7. P.3-14. (In Russian)

29.  Trahtengerts E. A., Pashchenko F. F. The results massing and self-synchronization in network-centric systems. Engineering and Automation Problems, 2017, no. 2, pp. 4-12 (in Russian).

30.  Trahtengerts E. A., Pashchenko F. F. Synergistic effects in network-centric systems. . Datchiki & Systemi, 2017, vol. 219, no. 11, pp. 3-12 (in Russian).

31.  Trahtengerts E. A., Pashchenko F. F. Some features of networkcentric control in largescale networks. Problemy mashinostroyeniya i avtomatizatsii - Engineering and Automation Problems. 2015. No.4. P.12-21. (In Russian)

32.  Trahtengerts E. A. Use of network-centred principle of self-synchronisation in management. Otkrytoye obrazovaniye - Open Education. 2015. Vol. 109. No.2. P.15-23. (In Russian)

33.  Arzumanyan R. V. Kromka Haosa. Slozhnoe myshlenie i set': paradigma nelinejnosti i sreda bezopasnosti XXI veka [Edge of Chaos. Complex thinking and networking: the nonlinearity paradigm and the security environment of the 21st century]. Moscow. Regnum Publ. 2012. 600 p. (In Russian)

34.  Ivlev A. A. Osnovy teorii Boida. Napravleniia razvitiia, primeneniia i realizatsii. Monografiia [Fundamentals of the theory of Boyd. Areas of development, application and implementation]. Moscow, 2008. 64 p.  Available at http://pentagonus.ru/_ld/0/23_KES.pdf (In Russian)

35.  ISO Focus+. The magazine of the International Standardization Organization. 2010. Vol.1. No.2. Available at: https://www.iso.org/files/live/sites/isoorg/files/news/magazine/ISO%20Focus%2b%20(2010-2013)/en/2010/ISO%20Focus%2b%2c%20February%202010.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019).

36.  New European Interoperability Framework. Promoting seamless services and data flows for European public administrations. Luxembourg. Publications Office of the European Union, 2017. 48 p. ISBN 978-92-79-63756-8 DOI: 10.2799/78681 Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/isa2/sites/isa/files/eif_brochure_final.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019).

37.  6 sostavlyayushchih Industry 4.0. [6 components of Industry 4.0]. PTM-Avtomatika, 2016. Available at: http://www.plm.pw/2016/09/The-6-Factors-of-Industry-4.0.html (accessed 21 October 2019). (In Russian)

38.  Olejnikov A. Ya. Problema interoperabel'nosti v platforme Industry 4.0. i smezhnyh oblastyah [The problem of interoperability in the platform Industry 4.0. and related fields]. Sbornik trudov IX Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii “IT-Standart 2019” [Proceedings of the IX International scientific conference “IT-Standard 2019”]. Moscow, MIREA - Russian Technological University, 2019. pp. 49-56. Available at: https://www.cksit-rspp.ru/upload/iblock/856/8569700483b0b1df880caf5f88f889cc.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019). (In Russian)  

39.  Kozlov S. V. Processnye aspekty interoperabel'nosti integrirovannyh sistem upravleniya [Process aspects of interoperability of integrated control systems]. Sbornik trudov IX Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii “IT-Standart 2019” [Proceedings of the IX International scientific conference “IT-Standard 2019”]. Moscow, MIREA - Russian Technological University, 2019. pp. 67-73. Available at: https://www.cksit-rspp.ru/upload/iblock/856/8569700483b0b1df880caf5f88f889cc.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019) (in Russian).

40.  Ilyushin G. Y., Sokolov I. A. Organization of users' manageable access to heterogeneous departmental informational resources. Informatika i eye primeneniya -  Computer Science and its Applications. 2010. Vol.4. No.1. P.24-40. Available at: http://www.mathnet.ru/php/archive.phtml?wshow=paper&jrnid=ia&paperid=15&option_lang=rus (accessed 21 October 2019) (in Russian).

41.  Golovin S. A., Andrianova E. G., Gudkova O. K., Laptev A. N. The methodology of the development of profiles of IT standards to provide the interoperability of complex distributed systems. Zhurnal Radioelektroniki - Journal of Radio Electronics. 2014. No.12. Available at: http://jre.cplire.ru/jre/dec14/16/text.html (accessed 21 October 2019). (In Russian)

42.  Akatkin Yu. M., Yasinovskaya E. D. Cifrovaya transformaciya gosudarstvennogo upravleniya: Datacentrichnost' i semanticheskaya interoperabel'nost' [Digital transformation of public administration: Datacentricity and semantic interoperability].Moscow, LENAND Publ. 2019. 724 p. Available at: https://urss.ru/elib/249005/# (accessed 21 October 2019) (In Russian).

43.  GOST R ISO 11354-1-2012. Usovershenstvovannye avtomatizirovannye tekhnologii i ih primenenie. Trebovaniya k ustanovleniyu interoperabel'nosti processov promyshlennyh predpriyatij. Chast 1. Osnova interoperabel'nosti predpriyatij [GOST R ISO 11354-1-2012. Advanced automated technologies and their application. Requirements for the establishment of interoperability processes of industrial enterprises. Part 1. The basis of enterprise interoperability]. Moscow, Standartinform Publ. 2014. 34 p. (In Russian)

44.  O tekhnicheskom komitete po standartizatsii «Informatsionnyye tekhnologii».[About technical Committee on standardization "Information technologies"]. Order of the Ministry of Industry and Trade of the Russian Federation, Federal Agency for technical regulation and Metrology dated April 22, 2016 No. 463. Available at: http://docs.cntd.ru/document/456004466 (accessed 21 October 2019). (In Russian).

45.  Kupriyanov A. A. Network-Centric Warfare and Some Questions of Interoperability of Computer-Aided Systems. Avtomatizatsiya protsessov upravleniya - Automation of Control Processes. 2011. No.3. P.82-97. (In Russian)

46.  Network-Centric Operations Industry Consortium (NCOIC). 2019. [online]. Available at: https://www.ncoic.org (accessed 21 October 2019).

47.  Systems, Capabilities, Operations, Programs, and Enterprises (SCOPE) Model for Interoperability Assessment. Version 1.0. NCOIC, 2008. 154 p.

48.  NCOIC Interoperability Framework and NCOIC Patterns Overview. NCOIC, 2008. 30 p. [online]. Available at: https://www.ncoic.org/images/technology/NIF_Pattern_Overview.pdf (accessed 21 October 2019).

49.  NCOIC Interoperability Framework (NIF v. 2.1) and NIF Solution Description Reference Manual (NSD-RM v. 1.2). NCOIC, 2008. 125 p.

50.  Ñîre Net-Centric Principles. Version 2.0. NCOIC, 2012. 27 p.

51.  Introduction to NCOIC Net-Centric Patterns. NCOIC, 2010. 26 p.

52.  Network Centric Analysis Tool (NCAT). Overview with Java Tutorial. Version 3.1 Build 150. NCOIC, 2010. 25 p.

53.  NCOIC White Paper on the Cybersecurity Landscape. NCOIC, 2013. 18 p.

54.  NCOIC QuadTrangle. NCOIC, 2016. [online]. Available at: https://www.ncoic.org/ncoic-quadtrangle/ (accessed 21 October 2019).

55.  NATO Interoperability Standards and Profiles. Volume 1: Introduction. C3B Interoperability Profiles Capability Team, 2018. 48 p.

56.  NATO Interoperability Standards and Profiles. Volume 2: Agreed Interoperability Standards and Profiles. C3B Interoperability Profiles Capability Team, 2018. 90 p.

57.  NATO Interoperability Standards and Profiles. Volume 3: Candidate Interoperability Standards and Profiles. C3B Interoperability Profiles Capability Team, 2018. 18 p.

 

For citation:

Kozlov S.V., Makarenko S.I., Oleinikov A.Ya., Rastyagaev D.V., T. E. Chernitskaya T.E. Interoperability problem in net-central management systems. Zhurnal Radioelektroniki - Journal of Radio Electronics. 2019. No. 11. Available at http://jre.cplire.ru/jre/dec19/4/text.pdf

DOI  10.30898/1684-1719.2019.12.4